[
  {
    "artifact": "review-result.attempt-1.json",
    "attempt_number": 1,
    "findings": [
      {
        "body": "The fingerprint hashes `simulation_core.py`, which is only a facade, but not the actual `simulation_engine/core.py`; it also omits `country_registry.py`, `tax_engine/col_index.py`, and the tax policy implementations such as `tax_engine/policies.py`. Changes to simulation math, country coverage, or COL/tax policy can therefore alter numeric results without failing this guard or requiring a manifest bump, contrary to the acceptance criterion. Expand `GOVERNED_MODULES` to cover the actual semantic implementations and registries.",
        "confidence": 0.99,
        "end_line": 20,
        "file": "tests/test_assumptions_version.py",
        "id": "F1",
        "severity": "P1",
        "start_line": 11,
        "title": "Governed fingerprint omits core simulation and policy modules"
      },
      {
        "body": "Every enqueue unconditionally stamps the new current receipt, but the PR adds no enqueue/replay path that also writes `source_assumptions_version` and `source_assumptions_version_state`; searches show those fields are only read/serialized. Thus a newly computed deterministic replay cannot satisfy the required distinction between its current version and the source run's receipt. The required replay test is also absent. Add a replay enqueue path that copies the source receipt into the separate source fields before compute and cover both declared and ambiguous legacy sources.",
        "confidence": 0.95,
        "end_line": 5356,
        "file": "storage/repository.py",
        "id": "F2",
        "severity": "P1",
        "start_line": 5354,
        "title": "Deterministic replay source-version provenance is never recorded or tested"
      }
    ],
    "reviewed_at": "2026-08-11T23:30:00-07:00",
    "reviewed_base_sha": "f085eb71c91d0fb492e14e4c87b49b62941ca0b7",
    "reviewed_head_sha": "8ac4dbf75c50914181749c48e6dbd6b336d15850",
    "reviewer_agent": "codex",
    "reviewer_role": "independent_pr_reviewer",
    "status": "request_changes",
    "summary": "The implementation does not provide the required CI tripwire over several core semantic registries/modules, and deterministic replay source-version provenance is not implemented or tested."
  },
  {
    "artifact": "review-result.attempt-3.json",
    "attempt_number": 3,
    "findings": [
      {
        "body": "The new fallback supplies the current receipt only when `run_id is None`. `_cancel_run` still calls `_base_provenance(payload[\"run_id\"])` without version fields, so cancelling any newly enqueued run now returns `assumptions_version: null` and `legacy_unverified`, despite that run having a persisted declared receipt. Fetch the owned run or include its receipt in the cancel response and pass both fields here; add an MCP cancellation contract test for a newly versioned run.",
        "confidence": 0.98,
        "end_line": 612,
        "file": "api/mcp/router.py",
        "id": "F1",
        "severity": "P1",
        "start_line": 605,
        "title": "Preserve the cancelled run's stored assumptions receipt"
      }
    ],
    "reviewed_at": "2026-08-11T23:30:00-07:00",
    "reviewed_base_sha": "04857d30517be9dfa2c84d40118f2b1a9f889e04",
    "reviewed_head_sha": "55756bdc728d3c69425401dc174709a36b667fe8",
    "reviewer_agent": "codex",
    "reviewer_role": "independent_pr_reviewer",
    "status": "request_changes",
    "summary": "The persisted version contract is implemented across primary enqueue/read/share paths, but MCP cancellation provenance regresses to an unverified null receipt even for newly versioned runs."
  },
  {
    "artifact": "review-result.attempt-4.json",
    "attempt_number": 4,
    "findings": [
      {
        "body": "`GOVERNED_SEMANTIC_MODULES` includes the exchange-rate provider but omits `currency_normalization.py`, which converts agent-authored monetary inputs into the simulation currency before validation/enqueue. Changes to its field registry or conversion logic can alter numeric results for the same caller input without changing this fingerprint, contrary to the acceptance criterion covering server-applied transforms and registries. Add that module (and update the recorded fingerprint) so such semantic changes require explicit version review.",
        "confidence": 0.98,
        "end_line": 37,
        "file": "assumptions_version.py",
        "id": "F1",
        "severity": "P1",
        "start_line": 15,
        "title": "Include currency normalization in the governed semantic fingerprint"
      }
    ],
    "reviewed_at": "2026-08-11T23:30:00-07:00",
    "reviewed_base_sha": "04857d30517be9dfa2c84d40118f2b1a9f889e04",
    "reviewed_head_sha": "4fd5137dcb8ecbcf52c76dfaf7cfa4d2b2f59d52",
    "reviewer_agent": "codex",
    "reviewer_role": "independent_pr_reviewer",
    "status": "request_changes",
    "summary": "The persisted version contract is implemented across run, grid, share, REST, and MCP paths, and the authoritative gates pass. However, the CI fingerprint omits a server-side transformation module that directly affects normalized simulation inputs, leaving a material gap in the required semantic-change guard."
  },
  {
    "artifact": "review-result.attempt-5.json",
    "attempt_number": 5,
    "findings": [],
    "reviewed_at": "2026-08-11T16:30:00-07:00",
    "reviewed_base_sha": "04857d30517be9dfa2c84d40118f2b1a9f889e04",
    "reviewed_head_sha": "4ecf54b404e94163679b25be708d6a3ade268628",
    "reviewer_agent": "codex",
    "reviewer_role": "independent_pull_request_reviewer",
    "status": "approved",
    "summary": "The implementation centralizes and persists simulation-semantics receipts, preserves legacy/source provenance across read and copy paths, exposes manifest discovery metadata, and adds appropriate contract tests. No blocking correctness, security, or acceptance-criteria issues were found in the introduced changes."
  }
]